Evaluating the socio-economic impacts of selected regenerated heritage sites in Europe

Labadi, Sophia (2011) Evaluating the socio-economic impacts of selected regenerated heritage sites in Europe. Project Report. European Cultural Foundation; Riksbankens Jubileumsfond 129p. ISBN 9789062820542 (EAN). [Book]

[img]
Preview
PDF
Sophia_Labadi_2008CPRA_Publication.pdf

Download (803kB)

Abstract (in English)

Over and over again, in much quoted research, a new orthodoxy is expounded: culture-led development or regeneration stimulates significant positive economic and social outcomes,including creating employment and strengthening of social cohesion, inclusion and collective identity. The methodology and findings of these publications are, however, being challenged, with critics regularly calling for more robust evidence on the socio-economic impacts of culture-based development or regeneration projects and for more rigorous evaluation of the shortcomings of such schemes. Such calls for improved evaluation are also a rejection of the more simplistic assertions and grandiose generalisations about the assumed benefits of ‘culture’. This research project is a response to that call and is based on in-depth analyses of four cases studies in England, France and Poland. In conclusion, the report stresses the importance of regionalising the regeneration process, to ensure that its benefits are shared geographically and are sustainable. It is critical of the very broad definition of ‘culture’ and ‘heritage’ used in all four schemes which, in aiming to target as wide a public as possible, has led to an emphasis on ‘spectacle’ and stimulation, resulting in superficial and trivialised cultural events, sometimes not in any way connected to the locality in which they are set. Secondly the report considers the main issues with the evaluation models and findings, which are highlighted all through this report. It draws attention to the lack of primary and secondary data available to the evaluators, which sometimes forced them to base their assessments on the broadest of estimates. Such lack of data prevented the possibility of constructing longitudinal series of data on the long-term impact of regeneration. Focusing on the three official evaluations (The Lowry, Liverpool Walk Ropes and Lille 2004), the report shows how they were flawed by from ‘optimism bias’ – they were overtly optimistic in the benefits delivery of the projects. Finally, no evidence was found linking the regeneration scheme to social cohesion and inclusion.

Item Type: Book (Project Report)
Authors:
AuthorsEmail
Labadi, Sophiasophialabadi@gmail.com
Languages: English
Keywords: Regeneration; Socio-economic impact; Socio-Economic aspects; Development; Cultural heritage; European Capital of Culture; Methodology; Evaluation; Development projects; Sustainability; Sustainable development; Culture; Local level; Cultural Policy; Impact evaluation; Research project; Community participation
Subjects: D.URBANISM > 04. Rehabilitation
E.CONSERVATION AND RESTORATION > 09. Social and economic aspects of conservation
J.HERITAGE ECONOMICS > 02. Economic impact of heritage
J.HERITAGE ECONOMICS > 04. Methodologies of evaluation
J.HERITAGE ECONOMICS > 05. Heritage and sustainable development
Name of monument, town, site, museum: Lille, France; Salford, England; Liverpool, England; Kazimierz, Krakow, Poland
Number of Pages: 129
ISBN: 9789062820542 (EAN)
Depositing User: Melle Sophia Labadi
Date Deposited: 04 Oct 2012 14:44
Last Modified: 04 Oct 2012 14:44
References: Annabel Jackson Associates (2000) Social impact study of Millennium Awards, Bath: Annabel Jackson Associates online at www.millennium.gov.uk/publications/awards_social_impact_study_2000.pdf (accessed November 2010)



Applejuice Consultants (2008) Social impact of Heritage Lottery Funded projects. Evaluation report on research conducted for the Heritage Lottery Fund during 2006–2007 online at:

<http://legacy.hlf.org.uk/HLF/Docs/ResearchAndConsultation/SocialImpactYR3FINALreport.pdf>

[accessed 06 August 2010]



Appleton, J (2004) ‘Where’s the art in that?’ Spiked 8 December. Online at http://www.spikedonline.com/index.php/site/article/1819/ (accessed November 2010)



Bailey C, Miles S and Stark P (2004) ‘Culture-led urban regeneration and the revitalisation of identities in Newcastle, Gateshead and the north-east of England’. International Journal of Cultural Policy 10(1), pp. 47–65

Bałaban M (1935) Przewodnik po żydowskich zabytkach Krakowa Krakow: B’nei B’rith BDRC Research (2009) Impact of HLF Funding 2005-2008, Visitor and Neighbourhood Surveys

2005-8; [online] Available at:

<http://legacy.hlf.org.uk/NR/rdonlyres/F170F9BE-9BB4-45BB-A81E-F96DE6719F8C/7858/Impact_HLF_Funding_2005_2008_Visitor_Neighbourhood.pdf>

[accessed 06 August 2010]



Belfiore E (2002) ‘Art as a means towards alleviating social exclusion: Does it really work? A critique of instrumental cultural policies and social impact studies in the UK’. International Journal of Cultural Policy, vol. 8, no. 1, pp. 91–106 Bent Flyvbjerg (2004) The British Department for Transport: Procedures for Dealing with Optimism Bias in Transport Planning. Guidance Document. London: Bent Flyvbjerg in association with COWI. Online at http://flyvbjerg.plan.aau.dk/0406DfT-UK%20OptBiasASPUBL.pdf (accessed December 2010)



Bianchini F (1993a) ‘Remaking European cities: the role of cultural policies’ in Bianchini F and References



Parkinson M (eds) Cultural policy and urban regeneration. The West European experience. Manchester: Manchester University Press pp 1–20



Bianchini F (1993b) ‘Culture, conflict and cities: issues and prospects for the 1990s’ in Bianchini F and Parkinson M (eds), Cultural policy and urban regeneration. The West European experience. Manchester: Manchester University Press, pp. 199–213



BOP (2009) Assessment of the social impact of participation in HLF-funded projects Final report; online at:

<http://www.hlf.org.uk/aboutus/howwework/Documents/HLF_Social_Impact_FinalReport_BOP_June_2009.pdf>

[accessed 06 August 2010]



Bourdieu P (2008) Political interventions London: Verso, p. 342 Buruma, I (1997) ‘Poland’s New Jewish Question’.New York Times Magazine, [online]3 August.

Available at: <http://www.nytimes.com/1997/08/03/magazine/poland-s-new-jewish-question.html?pagewanted=4>

[accessed 30 August 2010]



Casey B, Dunlop R and Selwood S (1996) Culture as commodity? The economics of the arts and built heritage in the UK London: Policy Studies Institute



Chambre de Commerce et d’Industrie de Lille Métropole(2004) Les visiteurs de la métropole lilloise - Enquête de satisfaction <http://www.grand-lille.cci.fr/territoire/pdf/Etude-tourisme-2004.pdf>

[accessed 30 August 2010]



Coalter F (2001) Cultural services: Realising the potential, research agenda, University of Edinburgh: Centre for Leisure Research Colomb C (2007) Making connections: Transforming people and places in Europe. Case Study of Roubaix, Lille (France). URBED & the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, [online] Available at:

<http://www.urbed.com/cgi-bin/get_binary_doc_object.cgi?doc_id=277&fname=extra_pdf_3.pdf>

[accessed 06 August 2010]



Comedia (2003) Releasing the cultural potential of our core cities: culture and the core cities.



Dedieu F (2004) Ce sont nos machines qui déménagent. L’Expansion. 01/05/2004



Department for Culture, Media and Sport (2005) Culture at the heart of regeneration. Summary of Responses. [online] Available at: <http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/+/http://www.culture.gov.uk/images/publications/cathr_summary_of_responses.pdf>

[accessed 06 August 2010]



Department for Communities and Local Government (2007) Regeneration: Adjusting for Optimism Bias in Regeneration, Projects and Programmes. General Guidance Note. London:

Department for Communities and Local Government. Online at: http://www.communities.gov.uk/documents/corporate/pdf/319434.pdf (accessed December 2010)



Dodd, J and Sandell R (2001) Including museums: Perspectives on museums, galleries and social inclusion, Leicester: Research Centre for Museums and Galleries. Online at http://www.le.ac.uk/museumstudies/research/Reports/Including%20museums.pdf

(accessed November 2010)



ECOTEC (2008) The economic impact of funding heritage: Case studies for 2007. London: ECOTEC



Ellis A (2005) ‘Can culture save downtown?’ The Platform, 4(3) AEA Consulting http://www.aeaconsulting.com/platform/Platform%200403.pdf (accessed December 2010)



European Commission (2004) Insecurities in European cities. Crime-related fears within the context of new anxieties and community-based crime prevention. Online at http://cordis.europa.eu/documents/documentlibrary/100124091EN 6.pdf (accessed November 2010)



Evans, G (2006) ‘Measure for measure: Evaluating the evidence of culture’s contribution to regeneration’, in Paddison R, and Miles S, (eds), Culture-led urban regeneration. London: Routledge, pp. 116-137



Evans G and Shaw P (2004) The contribution of culture to regeneration in the UK: a review of evidence. A report to the Department for Culture Media and Sport. London: London Metropolitan University



Fraser C and Baert T (2003) ‘Lille: from textile giant to tertiary turbine’. In Couch C, Fraser C and Percy S (eds) Urban regeneration in Europe. Oxford: Blackwell Gautrand J (2000) ‘Lille - La capitale des Flandres amorce sa reconversion dans le high-tech’



L’Expansion.com 07/12/2000. [online] Available at:

<http://www.lexpansion.com/economie/lille-la-capitale-des-flandres-amorce-sa-reconversiondans-le-high-tech_15750.html>

[accessed 06 August 2010]



Gignoux S and Quille F (2009) ‘Pourquoi Lille continue à miser sur la culture?’ La Croix, 12/03/2009. online at:

< http://www.la-croix.com/article/index.jsp?docId=2367612&rubId=786>

[accessed 06 August 2010]



Gold J and Gold M (2005) Cities of culture. Staging International Festivals and the urban agenda; 1851-2000. Aldershot: Ashgate Greenberg E (2005) ‘Poland faces property restitution claim’ Forward 11 February [online]

Available at: <http://www.forward.com/articles/2913/> [accessed 30 August 2010]



Griffiths, R (2006) ‘City/culture discourse: Evidence from the competition to select the European capital of culture 2008’. European Planning Studies, Vol 14 no.4, pp. 415-430

Gruber R (2002) Virtually Jewish. Reinventing Jewish culture in Europe. Berkeley: University of California Press

Glu, B. 2005. Culture & propagande « Lille 2004 », capitale européenne de la culture. Agone, pp. 7-26



Hall T (2004) ‘Public art, civic identity and the new Birmingham’. In Kennedy L (ed) Remaking Birmingham, London: Routledge, pages 63–71



Hansen T B (1995) ‘Measuring the value of culture’ European Journal of Cultural Policy Vol 1 No 2: 309–322



Helme M-O (2009) Mareille, capitale européenne de la culture 2013. Quand Lille montre le chemin. PSE. 69. Janvier 2009, pages 23–29. Online at http://www.tourismeculturel.net/offre-tourisme-culturel/titre-de-mon-deuxieme-article-287

(accessed December 2010)



Heumann, H (1999) Historia Żydów w Europie Środkowej i Wschodniej. Warszawa: Adamatan International Federation of Arts Councils and Culture Agencies (2006) Arts and culture in regeneration. D’Art Topics in Arts Policy, number 25. Sydney: International Federation of Arts Councils and Culture Agencies (Ifacca) online at: <http://www.ifacca.org/media/files/25Regeneration.pdf>

[accessed 30 August 2010]



Kadłubek W (1208) Chronica seu originale regum et principum Poloniae (Chronicles of the Kings and Princes of Poland)

Kraske M (2007) ‘Fighting for tradition: Budapest’s Jewish quarter under threat’ Der Spiegel. 19 April. onlin>e at:

http://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/0,1518,478207,00.html

[accessed 30 August 2010]



Labadi S (2008) Lieux de culture, inclusion et cohésion sociale. Unpublished report for the Charles de Gaulle Foundation Landry C, Bianchini F, Maguire M, and Worpole, K (1993) The social impact of the arts: A discussion document, Bournes Green, Stroud: Comedia Lavieville J-P (2006) Lille 2004, tremplin pour l’élargissement du public ? Séance plénière du Conseil économique et social régional, Région Nord Pas de Calais. 7 février. online at:

<http://www.nordpasdecalais.fr/ceser/articles/ART000125/2006-0702-avis_lille_2004.pdf>

[accessed 06 August 2010]



Lonely Planet (2008) Poland. London: Lonely Planet Publications Lonely Planet (2002) Poland London: Lonely Planet Publications



Lorente, P (ed) (1996) The role of museums and the arts in the urban regeneration of Liverpool. Centre for Urban History, University of Leicester (Working paper/Centre

for Urban History: 9) online at <http://www.ub.es/escult/epolis/liverpool/LiverpoolBook.pdf>
URI: http://openarchive.icomos.org/id/eprint/1238

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item

Metadata

Downloads

Downloads per month over past year

View more statistics

© ICOMOS
http://www.international.icomos.org
openarchive(at)icomos.org