Similarities and differences in the conservation and settings of the Great Wall in China and the Limesromanus as listed and planned World Heritage Sites

Visy, Zsolt (2005) Similarities and differences in the conservation and settings of the Great Wall in China and the Limesromanus as listed and planned World Heritage Sites. In: 15th ICOMOS General Assembly and International Symposium: ‘Monuments and sites in their setting - conserving cultural heritage in changing townscapes and landscapes’, 17 – 21 oct 2005, Xi'an, China. [Conference or Workshop Item]

[img]
Preview
PDF
1-32.pdf

Download (958kB)

Abstract (in English)

The Great Wall and the Roman Limes are the longest built constructions of the world. The Great Wall was established earlier and it is very likely that it influenced somehow the concept of the Roman limes. While the Great Wall is a continual built defense line, the limes runs along rivers or roads (in the desert), and has only in some sectors a built construction, like the Hadrian’s Wall. This sector and the Great Wall were inscribed into the World Heritage list in 1987. Both played a decisive role in the life of the peoples living in- or outside of them, and both influence our life, too. The Roman frontiers run in Europe through densely populated areas, especially where the wall was substituted by rivers like the Rhine or the Danube. Most Roman settlements in this region are covered by medieval and modern towns, settlements. Another threatening effect is the strong industrialization of the line of the limes, so the newly initiated multinational project of the Roman limes as a World Heritage site – now for 6 European countries – can not be prepared not easily. It is worth comparing their settings and conservation, discussing their similar and different features, and to give an account about the preparations as a WHS in Hungary.

Item Type: Conference or Workshop Item (Paper)
Authors:
AuthorsEmail
Visy, ZsoltUNSPECIFIED
Languages: English
Keywords: walls; World Heritage Sites; Roman limes; setting; conservation; comparative analysis; state of conservation
Subjects: M.WORLD HERITAGE CONVENTION > 03. World Heritage List
E.CONSERVATION AND RESTORATION > 07. Management
H.HERITAGE TYPOLOGIES > 28. World Heritage
E.CONSERVATION AND RESTORATION > 05. Sites
Name of monument, town, site, museum: The Great Wall, China; Frontiers of the Roman Empire, Germany and UK
UNESCO WHC Number: 438; 430
ICOMOS Special Collection: Scientific Symposium (ICOMOS General Assemblies)
ICOMOS Special Collection Volume: 2005, 15th
Depositing User: Jose Garcia
Date Deposited: 31 Oct 2010 13:03
Last Modified: 13 Jan 2011 19:14
References: 1. Altheim, F.: Weltgeschichte Asiens, I. Halle (Saale) 1947.

2. Bai Shouyi (ed.): An Outline History of China; Beijing, 1982.

3. Bárdi L.: Az ősi selyemút világa. Budapest 2003.

4. Bárdi L.: Homokba temetett karavánutakon. Budapest 2005.

5. Bergman, F.: Travels and Archaeological Fieldwork in Mongolia and Sinkiang: A Diary of the years 1927-1934 (included in Part IV of History of the Expedition in Asia 1927-1935, Sino-Swedish Expedition, Publication 26). Stockholm 1945.

6. Ecsedy Ildikó: Nomádok és kereskedők Kína határán. Budapest 1977.

7. Felföldi Sz.: Fára, papírra, selyemre és bőrre írt kharostī dokumnetumok. In: Abhivādana. Tanulmányok a hatvanéves Wojtilla Gyula tiszteletére. Szeged 2005, 131-144.

8. FitzGerald, P.: Az ősi Kína (Ancient China). Budapest 1989.

9. Graf, D. F.: The Roman East from the “Chinese Perspective” (with the assistance of Edward L. Dreyer), Palmyra and the Silk Road. Les Annales Archéologiques Arabes Syriennes 42, 1996, 199-216.

10. Graf, D. F.: Rome and China: Some Frontier Comparisons. In Zs. Visy (ed.): Proceedings of the XIXth Congress of Roman Frontier Studies. Pécs 2005, 000-000.

11. Harmatta, J.: Az ókori selyemkereskedelem történetéből. Antik Tanulmányok 12, 1965, 205-230.

12. Harmatta, J. (ed.): History of Civilizations of Central Asia I-II. Paris 1994.

13. Herbert, K.: The Silk Road: The Link Between the Classical World and Ancient China. Classical Bulletin 73/2, 1997, 119-124.

14. Leslie, D. D. – Gardiner, K. H. J.: The Roman Empire in Chinese Sources. Studi Orientali 115. Department of Oriental Studies, University of Rome, 1996.

15. Loewe, M.: The Campaigns of Han Wu-ti. In: Kierman, Fr. Jr. – Fairbank, J. K. (eds.): Chinese Ways in Warfare. Cambridge-Harvard 1974, 67-122.

16. Ma Yong – Sun Yutang: The Western Regions under the Hsiung-nu and the Han. In: Harmatta, J. (ed.): History of Civilizations of Central Asia. II. Paris 1994, 227-246.

17. Pulleyblank, E. G.: The Roman Empire as Known to Han China. Journal of the American Oriental Society 119, 1999, 71-79.

18. Rostovtzeff, M.: Gesellschaft und Wirtschaft im römischen Kaiserreich I-II. Leipzig 1931.

19. Stein A.: Ázsia halott szívében. Budapest 1985.

20. Stein A.: Romvárosok Ázsia sivatagjaiban. Budapest 1916 = Ruins of Desert Cathay, Personal Narrative of Explorations in Central Asia and Westernmost China, vol. II. London 1912.

21. Stein, A.: Serindia: Detailed Report of Explorations in Central Asia and Westernmost China, vol. V. Oxford 1921.

22. Zhang Ying-pin (bianzhe): Zhongguo lishi yu wenming; Beijing, 2003. http:/idp.bl.uk www.china.org.cn/english/2003/Jun www.meet-greatwall.org/english/

23. Baatz, D.: Der römische Limes. Berlin 1993.

24. Bechert, T. - Willem, W.J.H. (eds.): Die römische Reichsgrenze von der Mosel bis zur Nordseeküste. Stuttgart 1995.

25. Bogaers, J.E. - Rüger.C.B.: Der Niedergermanische Limes. Köln 1974.

26. Breeze, D.J. - Dobson, B.: Hadrian’s Wall. London 2000.

27. Breeze, D. – Jilek, S. – Thiel, A. : Frontiers of the Roman Empire. Edinburgh - Esslingen – Wien 2005.

28. Elton, H.: Frontiers of the Roman Empire. London 1996.

29. Euzennat, M.: Le Limes de Tingitane, La Frontière Méridionale, Ètudes d’Antiquités Africaines, Paris 1989.

30. Gassner, V. - Jilek, S. - Stuppner, A.: Der römische Limes in Österreich. Vienna 1997.

31. Gudea, N.: Römer und Barbaren an den Grenzen des römischen Daciens. Zalău 1997.

32. Kennedy, D.: The Roman Army in Jordan. London 2000.

33. Mirković, M.: Römer an der mittleren Donau. Römische Strassen und Festungen von Singidunum bis Aquae. Beograd 2003.

34. Petrović, P. (ed.): Roman Limes on the Middle and Lower Danube. Beograd 1996.

35. Visy, Zs.: The ripa Pannonica in Hungary. Budapest 2003.

36. Zahariade, M.: The Fortifications of Lower Moesia (AD 86-275). Amsterdam 1997.
URI: http://openarchive.icomos.org/id/eprint/302

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item

Metadata

Downloads

Downloads per month over past year

View more statistics

© ICOMOS
http://www.international.icomos.org
openarchive(at)icomos.org