Practicing a New Natureculture of Hope for Multifunctional Great Plains Rangelands

Wilmer, Hailey, Porensky, Lauren M., Derner, Justin D., Augustine, David J., Fernández-Giménez, María E., Ritten, John P., Briske, David D. and Peck, Dannele E. (2019) Practicing a New Natureculture of Hope for Multifunctional Great Plains Rangelands. In: 2018 US/ICOMOS Symposium "Forward Together: A Culture-Nature Journey Towards More Effective Conservation in a Changing World", November 13-14, 2018, San Francisco, California. [Conference or Workshop Item]


Download (1MB) | Preview

Abstract (in English)

PART 1. ADOPTING A LANDSCAPE APPROACH - Taking a Landscape Approach to Integrating Nature and Culture /// In the US Great Plains, multigenerational ranching livelihoods and grassland biodiversity are threatened by dynamic and uncertain climatic, economic, and land use processes. Working apart, agricultural and conservation communities face doubtful prospects of reaching their individual goals for multispecies sustainability. This study documents the journey of a group of public lands managers, conservationists, ranchers and researchers re-imagining and practicing a different future for the rangelands of the US Western Great Plains. Formed in 2012, the team manages an experimental cattle ranch on the shortgrass steppe (the Central Plains Experimental Range in Nunn, Colorado) via collaborative adaptive rangeland management (CARM). We examine the processes used for a series of meetings to revise management objectives (2016-2018). We do so through the lens of the natureculture concept. In the early days of CARM, the team established locally-relevant multifunctional goals and objectives. Revisions to these objectives reveal changes in the team’s conceptual understanding and related practice of rangeland management. We describe and discuss these changes as the beginnings of a new natureculture, based on a sense of place and grounded in hope, emerging from CARM. We consider how these insights can inform broader efforts to create better conservation outcomes within the project and beyond.

Item Type: Conference or Workshop Item (Speech)
Porensky, Lauren M.UNSPECIFIED
Derner, Justin D.UNSPECIFIED
Augustine, David J.UNSPECIFIED
Fernández-Giménez, María E.UNSPECIFIED
Languages: English
Keywords: Cultural landscapes; natural landscapes; agriculture; pastoralism; conservation of cultural landscapes; rural landscapes; steppes; management; nature culture integration; local communities; interdisciplinarity; sustainability; sustainable development; methodology; collaborative adaptive management; grassland bird conservation; sense of place; intangible heritage; ecological aspects; USA
Subjects: E.CONSERVATION AND RESTORATION > 06. Cultural Landscapes
E.CONSERVATION AND RESTORATION > 11. Legal protection and Administration
H.HERITAGE TYPOLOGIES > 02. Agricultural heritage
H.HERITAGE TYPOLOGIES > 06. Cultural landscapes
J.HERITAGE ECONOMICS > 05. Heritage and sustainable development
O.INTANGIBLE HERITAGE > 06. Knowledge and practices concerning nature and the universe
Name of monument, town, site, museum: Central Plains Experimental Range in Nunn, Colorado, USA
National Committee: USA
ICOMOS Special Collection Volume: 2018 US/ICOMOS Symposium
Depositing User: Mrs Lucile Smirnov
Date Deposited: 14 Jan 2020 10:58
Last Modified: 14 Jan 2020 10:58
References: Allen, Craig R, and Lance H Gunderson. 2011. “Pathology and Failure in the Design and Implementation of Adaptive Management.” Journal of Environmental Management 92 (5):


Augustine, David J, and Justin D Derner. 2012. “Disturbance Regimes and Mountain Plover Habitat in Shortgrass Steppe: Large Herbivore Grazing Does Not Substitute for Prairie Dog

Grazing or Fire.” The Journal of Wildlife Management 76 (4): 721–28.

Averill, James R, George Catlin, and Kyum K Chon. 2012. Rules of Hope. New York: Springer Science & Business Media.

Beratan, Kathi K. 2014. “Summary: Addressing the Interactional Challenges of Moving Collaborative Adaptive Management from Theory to Practice.” Ecology and Society 19 (1).

Briske, David D, ed. 2011. “Conservation Benefits of Rangeland Practices: Assessment, Recommendationas and Knowledge Gaps.” Lawrence, KS: Allan Press.

Briske, David D, J D Derner, J R Brown, S Dr Fuhlendorf, W R Teague, K M Havstad, R Li Gillen, Andrew J Ash, and W D Willms. 2008. “Rotational Grazing on Rangelands:

Reconciliation of Perception and Experimental Evidence.” Rangeland Ecology & Management 61 (1): 3–17.

Briske, David D, Nathan F Sayre, Lynn Huntsinger, Maria Fernandez-Gimenez, Bob Budd, and JD Derner. 2011. “Origin, Persistence, and Resolution of the Rotational Grazing Debate: Integrating Human Dimensions into Rangeland Research.” Rangeland Ecology & Management 64 (4): 325–34.

Chapin, F Stuart, and Corrine N Knapp. 2015. “Sense of Place: A Process for Identifying and Negotiating Potentially Contested Visions of Sustainability.” Environmental Science & Policy 53: 38–46.

Charmaz, Kathy. 2006. Constructing Grounded Theory: A Practical Guide through Qualitative Analysis. Sage.

Derner, Justin D, William K Lauenroth, Paul Stapp, and David J Augustine. 2009. “Livestock as Ecosystem Engineers for Grassland Bird Habitat in the Western Great Plains of North America.” Rangeland Ecology & Management 62 (2): 111–18.

Domínguez-Tejo, Elianny, and Graciela Metternicht. 2018. “Poorly-Designed Goals and Objectives in Resource Management Plans: Assessing Their Impact for an Ecosystem-Based

Approach to Marine Spatial Planning.” Marine Policy 88: 122–31.

Ellis, Colter. 2013. “The Symbiotic Ideology: Stewardship, Husbandry, and Dominion in Beef Production.” Rural Sociology 78 (4): 429–49.

Fuentes, Agustin, and Linda D Wolfe. 2002. Primates Face to Face: The Conservation Implications of Human-Nonhuman Primate Interconnections. Vol. 29. Cambridge: Cambridge

University Press.

Fuhlendorf, Samuel D, David M Engle, R Dwayne Elmore, Ryan F Limb, and Terrence G Bidwell. 2012. “Conservation of Pattern and Process: Developing an Alternative Paradigm of

Rangeland Management.” Rangeland Ecology & Management 65 (6): 579–89.

Glaser, Marion, Gesche Krause, Beate Ratter, and Martin Welp. 2008. “Human/Nature Interaction in the Anthropocene Potential of Social-Ecological Systems Analysis.” Gaia-

Ecological Perspectives for Science and Society 17 (1): 77–80.

Haraway, Donna Jeanne. 2003. The Companion Species Manifesto: Dogs, People, and Significant Otherness. Vol. 1. Chicago: Prickly Paradigm Press.

———. 2008. When Species Meet. Vol. 224. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press. Hobbs, Richard J. 2013. “Grieving for the Past and Hoping for the Future: Balancing Polarizing Perspectives in Conservation and Restoration.” Restoration Ecology 21 (2): 145–48.

Holmes, John. 2006. “Impulses towards a Multifunctional Transition in Rural Australia: Gaps in the Research Agenda.” Journal of Rural Studies 22 (2): 142–60.

Initiative, North American Bird Conservation, and US Committee. 2009. “The State of the Birds, United States of America, 2009.” US Department of Interior: Washington, DC. Vol. 5.

Jackson, Jerome A. 2006. “Ivory-Billed Woodpecker (Campephilus Principalis): Hope, and the Interfaces of Science, Conservation, and Politics.” The Auk 123 (1): 1–15.

Kachergis, Emily, Justin D Derner, Bethany B Cutts, Leslie M Roche, Valerie T Eviner, Mark N Lubell, and Kenneth W Tate. 2014. “Increasing Flexibility in Rangeland Management during

Drought.” Ecosphere 5 (6): 1–14.

Kachergis, Emily, Justin Derner, Leslie Roche, Kenneth Tate, Mark Lubell, Rachel Mealor, and Jim Magagna. 2013. “Characterizing Wyoming Ranching Operations: Natural Resource Goals, Management Practices and Information Sources.” Natural Resources 4 (1): 45.

la Bellacasa, Maria de. 2010. “Ethical Doings in Naturecultures.” Ethics, Place and Environment 13 (2): 151–69.

Latour, Bruno. 2012. We Have Never Been Modern. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Malone, Nicholas, and Kathryn Ovenden. 2016. “Natureculture.” In The International Encyclopedia of Primatology, 1–2. American Cancer Society.


Nightingale, Andrea J. 2011. “Beyond Design Principles: Subjectivity, Emotion, and the (Ir) Rational Commons.” Society and Natural Resources 24 (2): 119–32.

Plumwood, Val. 2006. “The Concept of a Cultural Landscape: Nature, Culture and Agency in the Land.” Ethics and the Environment, 115–50.

Porensky, Lauren M, Justin D Derner, David J Augustine, and Daniel G Milchunas. 2017. “Plant Community Composition after 75 Yr of Sustained Grazing Intensity Treatments in Shortgrass Steppe.” Rangeland Ecology & Management 70 (4): 456–64.

Rand, Kevin L. 2017. “Hope, Self-Efficacy, and Optimism Conceptual and Empirical Differences.” The Oxford Handbook of Hope. New York: Oxford University Press.

Roche, L M, B B Cutts, J D Derner, M N Lubell, and K W Tate. 2015. “On-Ranch Grazing Strategies: Context for the Rotational Grazing Dilemma.” Rangeland Ecology & Management 68 (3): 248–56.

Roesch-McNally, Gabrielle, J Gordon Arbuckle, and John Charles Tyndall. 2018. “Soil as Social-Ecological Feedback: Examining the "Ethic" of Soil Stewardship among Corn Belt Farmers.”

Rural Sociology 83 (1): 145–73.

Samson, Fred B, and Fritz L Knopf. 1996. Prairie Conservation: Preserving North America’s Most Endangered Ecosystem. Washington, D.C.: Island Press.

Sayre, Nathan Freeman. 2017. The Politics of Scale : A History of Rangeland Science. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.

Scheier, Michael F, and Charles S Carver. 1985. “Optimism, Coping, and Health: Assessment and Implications of Generalized Outcome Expectancies.” Health Psychology 4 (3): 219.

Shoop, Marvin, Susan Kanode, and Mary Calvert. 1989. “Central Plains Experimental Range: 50 Years of Research.” Rangelands Archives 11 (3): 112–17.

Smith, Arthur H, and William E Martin. 1972. “Socioeconomic Behavior of Cattle Ranchers, with Implications for Rural Community Development in the West.” American Journal of

Agricultural Economics 54 (2): 217–25.

Snyder, C Rick. 1995. “Conceptualizing, Measuring, and Nurturing Hope.” Journal of Counseling & Development 73 (3): 355–60.

Teague, Richard, Fred Provenza, Urs Kreuter, Tim Steffens, and Matt Barnes. 2013. “Multi-Paddock Grazing on Rangelands: Why the Perceptual Dichotomy between Research Results and

Rancher Experience?” Journal of Environmental Management 128: 699–717.

Westoby, Mark, Brian Walker, and Imanuel Noy-Meir. 1989. “Opportunistic Management for Rangelands Not at Equilibrium.” Journal of Range Management, 266–74.

Williams, Daniel R, and Susan I Stewart. 1998. “Sense of Place: An Elusive Concept That Is Finding a Home in Ecosystem Management.” Journal of Forestry 96 (5): 18–23.

Wilmer, Hailey, Justin D Derner, Maria E Fernández-Giménez, David D Briske, David J Augustine, Lauren M Porensky, and the CARM Stakeholder Group. 2018a. “Collaborative Adaptive Rangeland Management Fosters Management-Science Partnerships.” Rangeland Ecology & Management 71 (5), 646-657.

Wilmer, H.; L.M.Porensky, M.E.Fernández-Giménez, J.D. Derner, D.J. Augustine, J.P. Ritten, D.P. Peck. 2018b. "Community-Engaged Research Builds a Nature-Culture of Hope on North

American Great Plains Rangelands." Soc. Sci. 8, 22.

Wilmer, Hailey, and María E Fernández-Giménez. 2015. “Rethinking Rancher Decision-Making: A Grounded Theory of Ranching Approaches to Drought and Succession Management.” The

Rangeland Journal 37 (5): 517–28.

Wilson, Geoffrey Alan. 2007. Multifunctional Agriculture: A Transition Theory Perspective. Wallingford: Cabi.

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item



Downloads per month over past year

View more statistics